Isle of Wight Society objects to “intrusive” Guardhouse shower block plans in East Cowes

The Isle of Wight Society has joined growing calls to refuse what it describes as an “intrusive” plan to install toilet and shower facilities in the historic Guardhouse at Victoria’s Barracks, in East Cowes.

The proposal, submitted by the Cowes Harbour Commission, includes external doors, internal alterations, and a side extension. Acting for CHC, ERMC previously said the scheme would allow the Isle of Wight Council to “improve” a building of local importance, and support increased footfall and maritime activity in East Cowes.

However, in its objection the Isle of Wight Society said any development should enhance the heritage asset, not harm it. It argued the plans “relate negatively to the conservation and enhancement of the Guardhouse” and ignore its value within the wider Victorian grouping of barracks, parade ground, walls and railings.

The group also raised concerns about fencing that would separate the building from its historic relationship with the parade ground.

As an alternative, the society suggested reopening a disused doorway into a brick‑screened area on Columbine Road, allowing the Guardhouse to function as a shower block without berth‑holders entering the parade ground. This would enable “sensitive restoration” using non‑opening Victorian‑style doors and windows on the parade‑ground side. Fewer single showers, it added, would remove the need for what it called an “unsightly extension”.

In its Heritage Statement, ERMC said the conversion and 16‑square‑metre (19.1 square yard) extension represented a “heritage‑sensitive, conservation‑led scheme” that would preserve and enhance the building’s value.

Public consultation on application 26/00220/FUL closed on April 7.