IW Council has ‘no confidence’ in Southern Water

A similar spirit of unity carried through the second major motion of the evening, a simple declaration of no confidence in Southern Water. The motion, put forward by Cllr Les Kirkby was passed by 37 votes, with one abstention.

Cllr Kirkby asked councillors to resist tabling amendments to his straightforward motion “This Council expresses no confidence in Southern Water”, arguing that the issue should not become political and that the Council needed to send a united message on behalf of Island residents. His plea was respected.

The former Southern Water employee spoke about the company’s alleged “Substandard working practices and the destruction of our beaches and waterways.” He described how years ago the company had been warned by its workforce against changing from ground water supplies to river extraction – which he said was cheaper. He contrasted the Island’s position with that of Portsmouth, which still relies on groundwater – and has no water shortage and no hosepipe ban over the summer.

During the debate, councillors from all sides highlighted concerns over sewage discharges, environmental damage, flooding concerns, inadequate infrastructure and rising bills. Members pointed to Southern Water’s poor environmental performance record and concerns about wastewater capacity and pollution incidents affecting rivers, beaches and coastal waters around the Island.

The sole abstention came from Cllr Jonathan Bacon. Explaining his position, the Council Leader said he continued to meet regularly with Southern Water’s senior leadership and wanted to maintain a constructive dialogue with the company. He added: “They know what the outcome is going to be tonight and they have said openly on many occasions they know they need to do better.” Many councillors said they had lost trust that the company really wanted to do better, including Cllr Becca Cameron, who held up an advertisement from Southern Water in 2007 – headed “We’re sorry”.

After years of council meetings marked by political bickering, councillors repeatedly stressed how they agreed with each other.

Lawrence Gosden CEO of Southern Water said the company took the vote seriously. “It is a clear reflection of the strength of feeling on the Island and reinforces the need for us to rebuild trust through our actions.

“For Southern Water, this means a responsibility to demonstrate through our actions that we have listened and are delivering the improvements the Island expects. Our focus remains on delivering the commitments we have made, including our long-term investment and improvement plans. Ultimately, confidence in Southern Water will be rebuilt by what we deliver, not what we say.

“We will continue to work and engage directly with the communities we serve to deliver the improvements needed. That endeavour will be made much easier if we can work together constructively with councillors across the Island. We all want the same thing: better outcomes for the communities we serve.”