The Diocese of Portsmouth has started the process of legal action against the Isle of Wight Council, challenging its plans to close three Church of England primary schools. A formal ‘Letter Before Claim’ has been sent to the council, laying the groundwork for a potential Judicial Review. The schools identified for closure are Oakfield, Brading, and Arreton St George’s, alongside two non-religious schools, Cowes and Wroxall, as part of efforts to address surplus school places.

The diocese argues that the process undertaken by the council was flawed, citing a lack of consultation with key stakeholders and inconsistent criteria for school selection. Concerns have been raised about the impact on students with special educational needs and families from deprived areas, as well as a significant reduction in Church of England school places on the Island. The diocese also highlighted contradictions in the council’s reasoning, noting that some closures are tied to academic standards despite government guidelines discouraging this.

Jeff Williams, the diocese’s director of education, criticised the process as unclear and damaging, urging the council to reconsider its approach. He warned that the closures could set a dangerous precedent for future decisions and emphasised the need for collaboration to develop transparent and fair proposals.

The Diocese has given the council 14 days to respond but has stated its willingness to work together to address surplus school places constructively, prioritising the best interests of the Island’s children and families.