Freshwater housing plan refused after Heathfield Farm protest campaign

By Mal Butler Mar 30, 2026

Residents who protested against the development of Heathfield Farm camp site, Freshwater, were celebrating this week, after planning was refused for a proposed 60 home, and a large retail space.

Only last month, around 40 people braved the elements by waving placards raising concerns that the development would cause irreversible environmental loss within the Isle of Wight’s UNESCO Biosphere Reserve.

Local resident, Julie Newell, said: “This proposal raised serious concerns around ecological harm, particularly the impact on Heathfield Farm’s resident red squirrels. The Island is a safe haven for this declining species and preserving their habitats is essential and central to the Isle of Wight’s UNESCO Biosphere status.

“The site has been described as a ‘haven for birds and small mammals’, including barn owls, bats, newts, badgers, and slowworms.

“The refusal sends a clear message that development must be environmentally responsible and that irreplaceable ecosystems can’t be sacrificed for the sake of meeting housing targets. A huge thank you to all who’ve helped to safeguard this acclaimed conservation campsite.”

There were 89 public comments with only two in support of the plans and the application was opposed by local councillors and the parish council.

A report citing the reasons the application was refused, listed inadequate information on protected species and water drainage, impact on the Southampton Water and Solent Special Protection Area and Colwell Bay Site of Special Scientific Interest, lack of local healthcare facilities, and agreement not reached on a financial contribution to local rights of way.

For full refusal reasons, see application 24/00993/OUT at iw.observer/planning-portal.